[0:07]بسم اللہ الرحمن الرحیم پروگرام اعتراضات کے ساتھ میں ہوں انیقہ نصار ناظرین جہاں امریکہ اور ایران کے معاملات کے اندر سختی نظر اتی ہے وہیں کہیں نہ کہیں کسی نہ کسی طرح کی سی لچک بھی نظر اتی ہے ابھی نرمی کی خبریں انے لگی ہیں امریکی اخبار ہے وال سٹریٹ جرنل اس کے مطابق جو ایران کی ریکوائرمنٹس ہیں یو ایس اے سے اس کے ایران نے کچھ نرمی کا اظہار کیا ہے اور اس سے پہلے تھرڈے کو شام کو پاکستان کے تھرو امریکہ تک کچھ اور شرائط پہنچائی گئی تھی جس کے اوپر کل صدر ٹرمپ نے بڑا واضح طور پر کہہ دیا کہ وہ قبول نہیں ہے اب امریکی اخبار وال سٹریٹ جنرل کی حالیہ رپورٹ کے مطابق ایران نے امریکہ کے ساتھ امن مذاکرات کی بحالی کے لیے اپنی شرائط کے اندر نرمی کرتے ہوئے واشنگٹن کو ایک نئی تجویز ارسال کی ہے اس نئی تجویز کے اندر یہ کہا گیا ہے کہ جی ایران نے املائے ہرموس کو کھولنے اور سمندری ناکہ بندی بند کرنے کے عوض مذاکرات کی بحالی پر امادگی ظاہر کی ہے نئی تجویز میں امریکی ناکہ بندی کے خاتمے کو مذاکرات کے اغاز کے لیے بنیادی نقطہ قرار دیا گیا ہے ایران نے اپنے جوہری پروگرام سے متعلق تعطل کا شکار بات چیت کو دوبارہ شروع کرنے کے لیے اسے امریکی پابندیوں میں نرمی کے ساتھ مشروط کیا ہے ابھی رپورٹ کے مطابق دوسری جانب امریکی نیوز ویب سائٹ ہے ایگزیوس اور ایگزیوس کے اوپر اکثر اوقات ٹرمپ انٹرویو بھی دیتے رہتے ہیں ان کے مطابق امریکہ نے مذاکرات کی بحالی کے لیے جوہری معاملے کو ایک بار پھر ایجنڈے میں شامل کر لیا ہے وہ اس سے نہیں ہٹ رہا ہے ایگزیوس کا کہنا تھا کہ صدر ٹرمپ کے قریبی مشیر سٹیو وٹکوف نے مجوزہ معاہدے میں نئی ترامیم ایران کو بھجوا دی ہے سو یہ ٹو اینڈ فورتھ چل رہا ہے ترمیم کے تحت ایران کو یہ تحریری وعدہ کرنا ہوگا کہ وہ مذاکرات کے دوران افزودہ یورینیم کی کسی بھی قسم کی منتقلی نہیں کرے گا سو یہ صورتحال ہے لیکن یہ یہاں تک نہیں رکتا ہے اب یہ ٹو اینڈ فرو چل رہا ہے پاکستان کے تھرو چل رہا ہے اور ساتھ ہی ساتھ صدر ٹرمپ نے یہ بھی کہہ دیا ہے کہ ہم بیسکلی ایران کے سفاک رہنماؤں کے ساتھ اس ٹائم پر گفتگو کر رہے ہیں He has pictures and you know again said and reiterated nuclear issue is not going to happen and pressure is still on Iran, so what Trump is saying, listen I'm dealing with some quite brutal people right now and they're lovely country of Iran. We cannot give Iran a nuclear weapon Is there would use it on a place called Israel they'd use it in Europe guess we'd be we'd be next and it's not going to happen don't worry about it which part of our problem we don't know who the hell we're dealing with The only country in the world nobody wants to be a leader you know they say they say would anybody like to be president and there are no takers they used tuck boats and then we landed on top of it and we took over the ship We took over the cargo took over the oil it's a very profitable business who would have thought we were doing that we're like pirates we're sort of like pirates and I believe it'll snap back very very quickly as soon there's so much oil These ships are loaded up with oil they can't get out of the straight sort of like pirates Iran bhi ye keh raha tha ke Qazakon ki tarah treat kar raha hai USA lekin situation kuch is tarah se hai ke mamlaat abhi bhi stand still par nahi hai Mamlaat chal rahe hain aur dusri taraf Trump barha Pakistan ki tarif karte nazar aate hain ek journalist ne jo ke bzaahar Indian origin ki maloom hoti hai Pakistan ke hawale se aur jo Iran ke trade roots open kiye hain uske upar sawal kiya to Trump ne kaha ki mujhe malum hai aur main Pakistan ki bahut zyada izzat karta hoon lekin sirf yahin nahi Rana Sanaullah ne bhi kaha ke puri duniya bahut zyada Trump ke humari tarif kar rahi hai lekin social media ke kuch anasir aise hain jo ke propaganda kar rahe hain konsa propaganda sunen Social media mein baz log hain jinki zati ghatiya siyasat mar ka hak ke upar bhi unhone pehle pehle koshish ki thi Pakistan ke tashukhuss ko jo hai woh bigada jaye Woh to Pakistan ko nuksan pahunchane se bhi jo hai woh baz nahi rehte Pakistan ki tarif sirf Trump nahi kar rahe Saudi Arab bhi kar raha hai Iran bhi kar raha hai puri duniya kar rahi hai Koi tarif kare na kare lekin kuch siyasi anasir of course Pakistan Tahreek Insaf ko is time par sabse zyada important yeh lag raha hai ke Imran Khan sahab ko deal milegi nahi milegi release karenge nahi karenge deal se woh completely reject karte hain ke hume deal nahi chahiye lekin unki release ki ummeed bandhe hote hain lekin Rana Sanaullah ne kaha hai koi deal nahi milne wali hai sunen zara nahi koi deal nahi hai unke mamlaat jo hai woh ab adalatou ke sipurd hai adalataun se jo relief lena chahte hain woh yaqeenan apealou mein gaye hue hain aur wahan pe kanoon aur ain ke mutabiq faisle honge ab qanoon aur ain ke mutabiq faisle honge aur baat karni hai ya nahi karni kal mere program ke andar Rana Sanaullah sahab ne kaha ke un woh Mehmood Khan Achakzai se zati tor par baat karte rehte hain zati aur siyasi tor par aur wahan yeh is baat ka ittifaq zaroor hai ke siyasi doun ko siyasi mamlaat baith kar discuss karne chahiye lekin Mehmood Khan Achakzai sahab ne ek aur jo rift hai uske bare mein baat ki aur woh Pakistan Tahreek Insaf ke within aur especially Imran Khan sahab ki bahnon ke hawale se ek rift ki khabren gardish bhi kar rahi hain uske hawale se Salman Akram Raja sahab ek dafa phat bhi pade the he had completely limpassed the sisters to abhi Mehmood Khan Achakzai sahab kya farma rahe hain sunen zara Na koi narazgi hai na mujhe jahil aur chote log hain Imran Khan ki behenien humari behenien hain Raja Afaq ne kabhi bamari kabhi Asad Qaiser pe usme wo nahi tha usme sirf humari ye wo thi ki in jang ke halat mein agar hum khuda na khwasta woh karein toh log kahenge yaar Pakistan ko ek moqa mila hai aur yeh tahreek e tahaffuz Pakistan wale is baat ko nahi samjhte aur lage hue hain murdabad zindabad hum ne faisla kar liya Punjab mein gali gali kuche kuche zille zille jana hai logon ko hum yehi samjhana hai ki bismillah aise halat banaye ja rahe hain ki minus Imran Khan Ab Pakistan Tahreek Insaf Tahreek Tahaffuz Ain e Pakistan nai muhim ki Bismillah kar rahi hai Hukumat iske upar Sadqallahul Azim karegi ya nahi karegi yeh ek ahum sawal banta chala ja raha hai Mere saath jo mehmanan maujood hain is mozou ko discuss karne ke liye unka mutaarif karwa deti hu Pakistan Tahreek Insaf ke rehnuma aur deputy secretary ittilaat hain PTI ke Shaukat Yousafzai sahab humare saath maujood hain Thank you very much Shaukat Yousafzai sahab for joining me in the program Ikhtiar Wali Khan sahab humare saath maujood hain coordinator to the Prime Minister hain Thank you very much Ikhtiar sahab for joining me in the show Ikhtiar sahab matlab ek baat toh Rana sahab ki baat se samajh li jaye ke kisi qisam ki koi discussion nahi honi wo jo hum muzakarat karne ko tayyar hain agar opposition wale humare paas ain speaker ki baat us se baat karein hum se baat karne ko kahein to phir hum jo hai woh baat sunne ko tayyar hain Toh ab woh wali cheezon ke upar full stop lag gaya Ikhtiar sahab Bismillah rahmanir rahim bahut shukriya Anika ji ye dekhiye baat aisi hai na ke ego agar nahi hai lekin kuch tehzeeb bhi hoti hai kuch akhlaq ka dairah bhi hota hai aap ko Prime Minister ne teen char baar dawat bhi di phir akhri baar to unhone speaker ki sarbarahi mein opposition se muzakarat ke liye ek committee bhi bana di lekin aap jamhuri logon se baat nahi karna chahte the aap political colleague se baat nahi karna chahte the aap baat kahin aur karna chahte the woh aap se baat nahi karna chahte to jo deadlock hai ye toh inhone khud paida kiya hai maybe agar yeh log chale jayein aur speaker sahab ke paas baith jayein ke hum muzakarat ke liye aaye hain hum baat karna chahte hain dialogue karna chahte hain toh shayad baat cheet chal pade lekin agar aisi koi baat ho toh agar yehi log samjhte hain ke inko hum se baat karne ki zarurat nahi hai toh mere khayal mein hume bhi koi zarurat nahi hai majboori humari bhi nahi hai Toh ab na samjhen na completely Ikhtiar sahab nahi mere khayal mein jamhuriyat mein dialogue mein kabhi akhri na samjhen lekin is waqt ki jo present situation hai isme toh yahi surathal hai ke na hi samjhe matlab yeh hai nahi karna chahte hain toh hum inki minnat tarla hum koi nahi Nahi masla yeh hai ki jab aap karna chahte hain toh woh nahi karna chahte baat jab woh karna chahte hain baat toh aap nahi karna chahte baat fish chal raha hai Bali agar yeh karna chahte hain agar yeh karna chahte hain toh raste hazaar na aana chahen toh bahane hazaar Speaker ki Speaker of National Assembly custodian of the house woh maujood hain
[8:13]Nahi lekin phir aap log kehte hain na nahi yeh log baat karenge lekin inke paas authority nahi hogi Imran Khan sahab nahi karna chahenge koi baat yeh log baat kar bhi lein dekhein maine dekhein meri baat sunain meri baat sunain opposition leader jo hai woh inhone namzad kiya inka toh yeh khayal tha Imran Khan sahab ka ke usko hum nominate nahi karenge humne unko nominate bhi kiya usko notify bhi kar diya ab inko apne opposition leader par kitni reservations hain kitne inke khadshat hain kitne unke shikwe aur gile hain unke inse aur inke unse yeh toh inke ghar ka mamla hai na pehle yeh apne house ko toh in order karein jis party mein dehd darjan se zaid ke groups ban chuke hon Anika Nasar aap usme se kis kis ke saath baat karengi sabse pehle toh yeh khud tai karenge ke kya yeh Achakzai sahab ki sarbarahi mein dialogue karenge yeh Barrister Gohar ki sarbarahi mein baat karenge yeh Barrister Saif ki sarbarahi mein baat karna chahte hain yeh apne Parliament leader ke uske jo jo inhone namzad kiya hua hai sahi I understand your point yeh unki sarbarahi mein baat karenge I understand your point toh agar inki tayyari nahi hai toh hum kis cheez ki tayyari pakden Toh Shaukat Yousafzai sahab yeh wala point toh mujhe samajh aati hai ke kya Achakzai sahab ki taraf koi authority thi ya nahi thi kyunki unke paas authority nahi thi to hukumat hamesha yahi jawaz deti thi ki kyunki unke paas authority nahi hai hum baat nahi kar sakte Imran Khan sahab ke paas yeh authority hogi Mujhe yeh bata dijiyega aaj jo Achakzai sahab ne yeh baat ki koi narazgi nahi hai kisi qisam ka koi hum log koi aise log nahi hain woh un Imran Khan sahab ki bahnein humari bahnein hain Lekin isse pehle babange doh ye baat barrister Salman Akram Raja hain woh bhi kar chuke hain woh acha khasa criticize kar chuke hain isse pehle Ali Amin Gandapur criticize kar chuke hain Asad Qaiser ke upar bahnein criticize kar chuki hain Toh jo siyasi log hain aur bahnein hain unke andar rift toh hai jab mauka aa jaye jahan kehna pade ke humari narazgi nahi hai toh samjha jana chahiye ke narazgi hai Bismillah Rahman Rahim bahut shukriya dekhiye aapne do teen cheezein aapne is ek issue ke upar layein ek toh party ke andar Ikhtilafat dusra hukumat ke saath muzakarat Toh main toh shuru din se main is baat pe qayam hoon aur aaj bhi qayam hoon ke is hukumat ke paas Ikhtiar nahi hai kis cheez ka muzakarat Aaj bhi agar America aur Iran ke muzakarat ho rahe hain toh naam kiska liya ja raha hai ke kaun yeh sab kuch kar raha hai matlab isme toh Shahbaz Sharif baki sare minus ho gaye hain inka naam nahi hai Shahbaz Sharif sahab ka toh naam le rahe hain Shahbaz Sharif sahab ka toh naam le rahe hain Nahi nahi dekhiye president alag cheez hai na main ikhtiar ki baat karta hoon jo ikhtiyarat hai ikhtiyar Wali sahab ki baat nahi kar raha ikhtiyarat ki baat kar raha hoon Ikhtiar bhi aapke saath mein hai haan jiske paas honge wohi wohi nahi ikhtiar Wali toh unke paas hai na main isse keh raha hoon main ikhtiyar ki baat kar raha hoon jo unke paas nahi hai Toh main yeh kehna chahta hoon ki jab ikhtiyarat hi nahi hai to kya muzakarat kya hona kya nahi hona Warna aapko Sha Shawo keh rahe hain aapke paas bhi ikhtiar nahi hai aap keh rahe hain unke paas ikhtiar nahi hai aapke paas to ikhtiar Wali bhi nahi hai inke kehne ka maqsad kehne ka maqsad yehi hai na ke is waqt dekhiye bada issue is waqt hai na ke mulk inse chal nahi raha hai yeh credit ek taraf toh le rahe hain ke ji humne Iran aur America ki jang rukwai theek hai Achi baat hai nahi ye nahi le rahe credit Shaukat Yousafzai sahab woh Trump de rahe hain aur Iran de rahe hain ye credit nahi nahi khair ye inko bhi de de khair hai lekin jo asal credit hai ke aap apne mulk mein kitne kitna piece la chuke hain Kya aapne koi siyasi isteqam kitna lekar aaye hain ye aapke liye kaun karega ye America ke hawale karenge aap ya phir Iran se darkhwast karenge ki jaye ab humara masla hal karein sabse ahum masla toh aapka apna hai aapka apna stake kamzor hoga toh aap bahar kaise aap apne andar dekhiye acha toh mujhe mujhe yeh baat samjhayen main main is baat ko appreciate karti hoon ke us time par jab sarbrahan ne aana tha toh aap logon ne apni Rawalpindi wala jo jalsa tha usko mansoob kiya this is a positive step isme koi shakk ki baat nahi hai Toh ab mujhe bataiyega ab ye jo muhim aap log dobara chalane lage hain iska ultimate goal kya hai ya ye Khanapuri hai Dekhiye humne ek acha kaam bhi kiya danishmandana kaam bhi kiya lekin uska response kya aaya ye bhi aap dekhen na kya response aaya Ek acha step tha na aur aur ek acha step tha aur usse hukumat jo hai agar unke paas ikhtiyarat hote to woh fayda utha sakti thi leadership se baat ho sakti thi thodi bahut relief de sakti thi Imran Khan ko lekin nahi di na behenou ko relief mili na Imran Khan ko relief mili na party ko behenien toh nahi chahti thi nahi Shaukat Yousafzai sahab behenien toh nahi chahti thi ke aap woh mansoob karein woh toh keh rahi thi go ahead karein Nahi dekhiye party toh Imran Khan ki hai na nahi maine kaha party toh Imran Khan ki hai na Imran Khan ko toh relief milna chahiye behenien Imran Khan ki hai na kamaz kam jo unke ilaaj ka masla hai kamaz kam unka ilaaj ka jo masla hai woh toh hal hona chahiye tha na uske saath to itni badi zyatti nahi honi chahiye thi lekin ab main jo asal cheez pe aana chahta hoon Dekhiye hukumat jo hai woh completely nakam ho chuki hai sirf iske piche na chupe aaj jo 400 rupay pe petrol aapne pahuncha diya log mehangai ka toh rul rahe hain aapke karkhane band ho rahe hain aapke berozgar khatam ho raha hai this is an international issue na Shaukat Yousafzai sahab I agree with you I agree with you Har ek paise ka I agree with you har ek paise ka theek baat hai Shaukat Yousafzai sahab ye sabse bada issue hai is waqt lekin aap America aur Iran ke muzakarat se bada issue ye hai Isme kuch Pakistan kar nahi sakta Shaukat Yousafzai sahab acha Anika dekhein main aapko ek baat batata hoon acha aap hote toh aap kya karte aap yeh bataiye na aap hote aapki government hoti toh kya karte dekhein main agar humari hukumat hoti to kya Corona ke andar Imran Khan ne petroleum levy ko zero nahi kiya tha kya yeh baat galat hai Corona ke andar petroleum masnoat ki istemal ke andar kami ho gayi thi toh uski price kam ho gayi thi woh toh acha time tha Woh toh acha time hai na ke abhi inhone dekhein dekhein meri baat sunain jo dekhein ye hikmat amli aap dekhein na government ki aap dekhein ke 400 arab 400 arab dollar hai ya 400 arab mein main abhi isme confuse ho raha hoon yeh par week aapko nuksan ho raha hai Pakistan ko jo aapne yeh lockdown kiya hai Toh ye aapko unse koi Pakistan ke liye kamai kar rahe hain ya Pakistan ko aur nuksan pahuncha rahe hain hum toh karzon mein doob rahe hain logon ki already matlab woh karobar tabah hai aur aap unko aur tabah kar rahe hain ke aaj 8 baje dukanein band karein koi fayda toh bataiye na us waqt Corona tha khauf tha logon ke andar yeh nahi tha ke koi energy crisis bana rahe the hum us waqt khauf tha us khauf ki wajah se lockdown karna majboori tha Nahi lekin phir bhi us time par bhi dukanein band thi iske bawjood hikmat amli yeh thi ke humara jo levy jo tha woh zero kar diya gaya tha Abhi inhone dekha na 100 rupay levy to already le rahe the ye ab dekhein tijarati khasara jitna badha hai aap agar aap aapka FBR agar paise nahi collect kar sakta aapka target pura nahi hota toh aap bojh in IMF ke saath anban bhi ho gayi thi na Shaukat Yousafzai sahab aap logon ki IMF ke saath anban bhi ho gayi thi na Woh anban jo hui thi nahi agar woh anban hui thi toh woh sari zindagi ab yahi chalta rahega nahi hona chahiye hume toh IMF ki taraf jana hi nahi hai acha aur uski wajah se default ki taraf bhi ja rahe hain aapka leader ne jo Imam Khan sahab ne muhaide kiye the na jo Imran Khan sahab ne muhaide kiye the main unka woh muhaida February 2021 ka main assembly par le aaya tha
[15:43]mere mohteram bhai Shaukat Yousafzai sahab us ijlas mein baithe hue the aur maine haath mein utha kar inko keh diya tha ke aapka leader petrol aur Bijli ke yeh yeh kimten tai kar ke aaya hua hai yeh IMF ka woh muhaida hai aur maine inko challenge kiya tha koi isko jawab nahi de sakega phir uske baad jab aapki hukumat khatam hui toh aapne wohi muhaida jo IMF ke saath kiya tha woh aapne tod diya aapke leader ne tod diya aur phir uske baad aapka leader yeh kehta gaya ke ab Pakistan default hoga toot jayega teen tukde ho jayega aur Sri Lanka ban jayega humne us Pakistan ko tootne se aur default hone se bacha liya chalain acha Economy wale segment ko main ne separately karna Ikhtiar sahab mujhe ab kyunki khatam ho raha hai waqt is segment ke liye mujhe quickly bata dijiyega ke inki muhim Pakistan Tehreek Insaf Tahreek Tahaffuz Ain e Pakistan inki muhim start ho rahi hai hukumat ka kya laye amal hoga bilkul jis tarah political parties ke saath hoga humne samajhte hain ke politically inko aur democratically inko tamam rights hasil hain agar ye koi movement bhi karte hain uske liye bhi koi mumanayat nahi hai lekin uske liye thodi si yeh assurance honi chahiye ke woh 26 November jaise qatl o ghartgari na ho danga fasad na ho 8 October jaise waqiat na ho 9 May jaise waqiat na ho toh ye mulk aapka hai ye jamhuriyat hai Pakistan ki hai political activities kar sakte hain yeh shurity aapko kis se chahiye Tahreek Tahaffuz Ain e Pakistan ke Achakzai sahab se barrister Gohar se Imran Khan sahab se kisi aur se kis se chahiye Definitely jo jo jo bhi isko lead karega uske jo jo bhi isko karenge qiyadat karenge woh sab hazraat jo hai woh ye assurance dein ke yahan par isme Shaukat Yousafzai sahab very quickly kya aap ye assurance de sakte hain nahi mere khayal se assurance toh government ko dena chahiye ke woh Punjab Police ko istemal nahi karegi beja aur riyasati taqat ka istemal nahi karegi humne kaunsi taqat ka istemal kiya hai humare hum toh jate hain aur hume yeh dandoun se marte hain kabhi goliyan marte hain kabhi kya karte hain main yeh keh rahi hoon ke woh jo assurance mang rahe hain aap jo shority mang rahe hain woh toh main unse puchungi lekin woh jo shority mang rahe hain ke aap log tear gas nahi lekar aayenge woh jo uski jo gans hoti hain ya koi aur gan ya jis tarah Ali Amin Gandapur sahab lekar aate the machinery woh nahi lekar aayenge uski shority aap log denge nahi nahi dekhein pehle bhi humare worker nehte the aaj bhi rahenge dekhein hum siyasi log hain siyasi jaddo jehad karna koi gunah nahi hai hum bilkul yeh shority main zaroor de sakta hoon apni party ki taraf se ke na pehle hum kabhi humne is tarah ki tashaddud ki ka kabhi socha hai na aayinda sochenge na kabhi is tarah haan ye jo aap police ki baat kar rahe hain woh us waqt ke wazire aala the unke saath security hoti thi usko ye is tarah se istemal kiya Shaukat Afridi sahab bhi layenge is tarah ki cheezein nahi to humla humla kar nahi security toh hoti hai kisi bhi wazire aala ke paas hoti hai uske andar ambulances cranes woh cheezein bhi hongi uska hargiz matlab yeh nahi hai ke aap usko aapne dekha na ek wazire aala to tha Ali Amin Gandapur jo bhi tha lekin kya us pe aapne goliyan nahi barsain yeh kaunse qanoon kaunse mulk mein aisa hota hai ke ek jamhuri mulk ke lane wala aur jamhuri system banne wala wo aap kya aap kisi bhi kya yahan PDM ka jo jalsa ho raha tha Peshawar ke andar humne unko pani farahum nahi kiya tha humne unko jagah farahum nahi ki thi Sindh mein bhi aapko welcome kiya tha Sohel Afridi sahab ne lekin waqt khatam ho gaya Shaukat Yousafzai sahab thank you very much Ikhtiar Wali sahab thank you very much dono ko rothi chahiye dono ko shority nahi mil rahi kachi pakki mil jaati hai lekin uske baad kya hota hai woh aapke samne hai baharal yeh muhim start hogi toh we will keep an eye on that as well break ki taraf jate hain break ke baad International issues ki taraf bhi jayenge Iran USA and of course Afghanistan as well
[19:56]Welcome back after the break break pe jane se pehle hum zara siyasi aur international affairs ki baat kar rahe the Khurram Shehzad sahab humare saath maujood hain jo ke mushir hain wazir e khazane ke and finance ministry ke andar bahut sari changes karni padi hai rad o badal karni padi hai is war ne bada impact kiya hai negatively Pakistan ki maishat ko bhi and we are again back to double digits of inflation jisko badi mushkil se single tak lekar aaye the Khurram sahab thank you very much for joining me in the program it's a pleasure having you in the show Khurram sahab kya aaj hum jahan maujood hain because of the war agar hum isse zyada stable situation mein hote meri aap se December mein baat hui thi And I talked about ke humne exports ke upar koi kaam nahi kiya export numbers hamare badhe massively reduce the bahut bahut zyada undermined the We could have done so much better if we were at a better position to aaj hum is situation mein hote ya na hote Ji bismillah rahmanir rahim thank you very much ji pehle to main thoda sa context de do aapko global economy ka dekhiye is waqt war situation hai aur aapko pata hai kisne salah salah kar ke sefire karwaya hai duniya ko ek bahut bade impact se bachaya hai for the time being dekhein number one Pakistan ka agar aap puri duniya mein context dekhe to Pakistan ki resources dekhe aur Pakistan ki at home management dekhe aapko farak nazar aayega agar aap global impact dekhe to takriban koi teen se char percent global economy pe impact aaya hai in terms of cost in terms of inflation in terms of trade disruptions you know shipping lines ki cost badh gayi aur food ki cost badh gayi to total jo inflation hai woh 200 basis point increase ki baat ho rahi hai global aapko pata hai 200 basis point bahut bada impact hota hai kyunki duniya ki inflation chalti hai dedh percent do percent teen percent aur usme 200 basis point ka matlab hai double se bhi zyada secondly jo growth hai agar global economy ki growth char percent expect ki ja rahi hai sare teen ki ja rahi hai to woh keh rahe hain ki woh niche dedh percent se niche aa jayegi ya do percent se niche aa jayegi yani ke growth ka niche aana aur inflation ka badh jana stagflation kehte hain isko ke growth se zyada mehangai mein izafa ho raha ho toh ye naturally jo hai ek impact hai duniya ka aur jo main teen se char percent keh raha hoon na woh monetary terms mein sare teen trillion dollars hai 3500 arab dollars hai yeh impact hai duniya ka number one yeh context main batana cha raha hoon ke global economy ka impact kya hai Pakistan ka impact dekhe to Pakistan ka impact March ke mahine mein current account pe jo hai rather bada bada behtar aaya relatively uski wajah yeh hai ke Pakistan ki remittances jo hai na woh woh you know strong rahi Pakistan ki IT exports strong rahi 20 20 percent se grow kar rahi hain third jo hai Pakistan ki jo growth hai na first half mein woh 3.9 percent hai GDP growth ki main baat kar raha hoon 3.9 percent 3.8 percent in fact aur Pakistan ki inflation pehle se kam thi relatively Pakistan ki inflation isse pehle chal rahi thi on average 5 percent sawa 5 percent yeh do mahine ka impact inflation ka aaya hai naturally aaya hai kyunki woh aapko pata hai prices pass on ki gayi hain aur saath saath global economy ka impact aapko indirectly shipping cost or trade cost ye sab padti hain to main yeh kehna cha raha hoon ke Pakistan ka global context ke hisab se bahut behtar manage hua hai aap dekhe kisi ek petrol pump pe aapko koi law and order ki situation nazar nahi aayi hogi koi law and order ki situation aap dekhein India mein 700 billion dollars ke reserves hain India ke Woh toh aapne pass on kar diya na awaam ki taraf rationing toh tab hoti jab awaam jab awaam tak pass on nahi hota nahi pass on toh hua lekin saath mein aap yeh bhi dekhe na ke jo support di gayi hai woh pehle nahi di gayi
[23:40]aapne yeh kiya ke aapne jo afford kar sakte hain unko market price pe petrol ya diesel mile lekin jo vulnerable segment hai yani ke motor bikers hain motor cyclists hain ya phir jo hai woh diesel ki gadiyan hain jisse aapki transport hoti hai food product ki unko jo hai support di gayi railway ke kiraye nahi badhaye gaye ab Prime Minister ne ek mahina aur bhi aage kar diya aapne dekha hoga ek mahina extend kar diya hai price bhi badhaye hai lekin ek mahina aage bhi kar diya hai to balancing act jo hai government of Pakistan karti ja rahi hai yeh badi important cheez hai manage kiya hai behtar inko acha is budget ke andar jo levy hai that is a major issue woh levy kam ki thi diesel ke andar kam ki thi petrol ke andar badha di uske baad petrol ke andar teen rupay cheez kam ki uske baad diesel ke andar badha di considering this kya hum IMF ke saath koi is time par koi bargain nahi kar pa rahe hain they know ke duniya ke andar kya ho raha hai koi hum Pakistan alag toh nahi hai na nahi IMF ke saath baat ki thi na aap dekhein agar main thoda sa aapko piche lekar jao March ki shuru mein agar aap dekhein jab aapko pata hai pehle hafte mein prices Pakistan ne badhai thi uske agle do ya teen hafte prices nahi badhi thi aur duniya mein double triple ho gayi thi price aap dekhein diesel ki kimat jo thi woh 77 78 dollars se uth ke 88 dollars se uth ke 250 dollars pe gayi hai aap aap sochein baat ke 250 dollars pe jana 88 dollars se kitna bada impact hai aur dusra mil nahi raha tha na product Pakistan ne strategic taluqat jo hai woh woh you know exercise kiye hain aur phir mil gaya nahi main main thoda sa context de raha hoon ke do mahine mein jab prices nahi badhi government ne kya kiya government ne IMF ke saath discuss kiya IMF ne bhi kaha ke theek hai aap apne austerity karein apne kharche kaate aur saath mein aap jo hai aapko 151 ya 150 arab rupay tak ka aapko usme room hai aap de sakte hain jab 150 arab pe pahuche toh phir aapne dekha ke provinces ko saath soo ko saath liya ke ji aap bhi thoda thoda saath dein manage karna shuru karein aapne dekha hoga ke jab se austerity measure aaya yani ke ye jo bikers ko motor cyclist ko 2000 rupay par mahina dena shuru kiya 75000 rupay se lekar 1 lakh rupay tak jo hai diesel ki gadiyon ko jo hai woh subsidy dena shuru ki aur jo agriculture jo choti zameen hain unko support karna shuru kiya diesel ke andar jo pricing hoti hai kisano ko toh kisne kiya woh woh provinces ne saath mil ke kiya yani ke federal ne apna role pehle play kiya phir provinces ne play kiya aur phir ab ja ke yeh hua hai ki aapke paas pehle do dhaai hafte ke jo reserves the aaj char hafte ke reserves bhi aapke paas Allah ka shukr hai hain fuel ke yani ke aapko supply ensure karni hai pehle aur aage bhi subsidy dene ki koi imkanat nahi dekhein subsidy ki baat nahi kar raha main main keh raha hoon ki dekhein dekhein ye na fluid situation hai
[26:36]yeh bada acha sawal hai aapka yeh bada fluid situation hai ke ji aaj agar let's say agle hafte mein kuch resolution nikal aata hai I am sure nikal aayega kyunki jis tarah se aasan nazar a rahe hain baat ho rahi hai asal to aise hain just on a side note hain aisa waqe mein asar nahi bilkul hai na asar kyun nahi hai aap dekhein Iran ne do martaba apni jo hai woh tajawiz di hain dekhein woh toh woh toh abhi aapko front pe toh koi baat nahi karega na back end pe sare channels kaam kar rahe hain ye aapko Inshallah nazar aayega lekin main keh raha hoon ummeed hai ummeed bahut achi hai lekin main batata hoon worst case ki surat mein Prime Minister ne jo National Coordination Management Council banayi hai na woh char cheezein dekhiye mujhe sirf 30 seconds dein usme energy pehle finance minister ke under jo hai na energy prices ko dekha ja raha tha volumes ko dekha ja raha tha demand ko dekha ja raha tha kahan se kis tarah se source karna hai woh dekha ja raha tha aaj ye expand hoke energy se food commodities supply chain and finance sari cheezein trade bhi uske andar hai ye sab cheezein bit par dekhi ja rahi hain ke kiska agar scenario analysis ho raha hai ki agar let's say yahan se jang nahi rukti misal ke to par dobara koi hamla ho jata hai worst case lekar chalna hai na humne toh hum toh ye nahi keh sakte best case lekar chalein hamesha government ka kaam hota hai worst case lekar chalna ke sabse worst case aa jaye to usme kya karenge woh agar aapne cover kar liya toh aap naturally phir sari cheezein cover kar sakte hain usme yeh hai ki aapke paas is waqt fuel behtar hai supply aapki insured hai aapki Saudi Arabia se financing arrange hui hai Saudi Arabia se aage jo hai extension ki baat ho rahi hai jo deferred us pe aapko oil milta hai na kimat baad mein de dein aaj aap oil fuel le lein hame woh at least milti ja rahi hain cheezein aur hum saath saath humara jo reserves hain woh behtar hain current account behtar hai so my question still stands ke hum log ye subsidy jo de rahe hain ye kab tak sustain kar sakte hain maine kaha ek ek mahina aage kar diya hai abhi filhal theek hai zarurat padegi toh mazid aage ki ja sakti hai lekin baat yeh hai ke aapko kahin na kahin pe limit define karni hogi na dekhein reforms bhi chal rahe hain saath saath abhi tak so far so good lekin main yeh kehna cha raha hoon ke hopefully prices ek 100 dollar pe bhi rehti hai to hum yeh manage kar sakte hain somehow lekin usse upar gayi agar to for example for example agar jang aaj khatam ho jati hai kal khatam ho jati hai agle hafte khatam ho jati hai even then bhi petroleum masnoat ki production toh us tarah se start nahi ho sakegi na it takes time to restart all that toh woh uska impact hum logon ne kitne arse ka socha hua hai dekhein mujhe lagta hai hamara jo ek plan hai woh yeh ke kam se kam dekhein ye global ek scenario analysis hai ke kam se kam teen se char mahine lag sakte hain zyada bhi lag sakte hain restore hone mein yani ke ye jo 20 percent supply ud gayi hai samjhein aap jab ud jati hai koi cheez toh usko fill in hone mein ya usko usko jo hai us khala ko pur karne mein thoda waqt lagta hai kyunki alternate pipelines dalti hain alternate routes hain aap dekhein aapko main thoda sa recall karwata hoon jab Russia aur Ukraine ki jang hui thi us waqt bhi 100 dollar 120 usse bhi zyada kimten gayi thi phir wapas aa gayi thi but pure saal ki average 100 dollar hui thi but that doesn't have a bigger global impact jitna iska hona chahiye bilkul sahi baat hai supply ka itna bada issue nahi hai lekin main phir wohi keh raha hoon jab prices badhti hain na toh naturally ek main aapko silver lining batata hoon iske baad naturally jo hai na supply dusre jo players hote hain woh lana shuru kar dete hain kyunki price ek khud incentive hota hai na badi prices hoti hai incentive hota hai ki supply aur lekar aaye
[30:26]main yeh bata raha hoon ki Opec ke andar UAE ke nikalna mujhe lagta hai ye silver lining hai kyunki cartel jo hota hai na duniya mein koi bhi cartels hote hain woh cartels bante hi isliye hain ki woh price ko bhi manage karein aur supply ko bhi manage karein toh agar cartel kamzor hota hai to usme kiska fayda hoga consumer ka fayda hoga kyunki jo bhi jo bhi player niklega woh uska compliant nahi hoga na woh kahega mujhe zyada kyunki unke yahan impact zyada aaya hai terrorism ka investment ka toh unko chahiye ke supply zyada lana supply zyada layenge to prices Inshallah niche aayengi aur obviously thoda sa ek aur woh toh straight of Homos ki side pe bhi hoke guzar sakta hai they can do that but but ek aur khabar kyunki aapne UAE ki baat kar di hai badi gardish kar rahi hai aur aap finance ministry se taluq rakhte hain to you will be able to tell us better hamare human resource ke saath kuch unfair situation ho rahi hai yeh khabren gardish kar rahi hain social media pe I want a denial or a confirmation nahi dekhiye denial to aapko MoFA de sakta hai proper kyunki hum toh finance ki taraf se dekhte hain lekin mera main aapko batata hoon ke dekhein abhi tak jo understanding hai woh aisi nahi hai jiss tarah se court kiya ja raha hai Pakistan aur UAE ke taluqat aise nahi ho gaye hain ki ji aap dekhein aap humare paas investments hain unki aap petroleum sector mein investment hai unki unki finance sector mein investment hai unki unki telecom mein investment hai itni badi ye cheezein is waqt mere khayal mein is tarah ki baat karte hain bagair hum research kiye hue ya bagair detail kiye hue toh ye thodi si thoda sa mujhe lagta hai irresponsible ho jati hai nahi pure social media pe ghum raha hai je main aapko batata hoon dekhein aap airlines ki baat ho rahi hai na woh aap Etihad wali baat kar rahi hongi ki Etihad airways se Pakistani nikal diye hain aap utha ke zara dekhein duniya ki kitni airlines jo hai woh is waqt khasaare mein ja rahi hain aur sabse zyada bechare ye Middle East wale hain kyunki inka scale bahut bada hai toh naturally trim karenge na HR ko dekhein ek cost hoti hai oil oil ki energy ki cost hoti hai airline ke liye chalane ke liye second cost aapki human resource hoti hai toh naturally jab oil jo hai niche nahi a raha aur unke yahan jo hai 50 50 hazaar flightein cancel ho rahi hain duniya bhar mein Western airlines hon ya aapki Middle Eastern hon aur uske saath agar woh retention karte hain to across the board hogi Pakistanis ke saath kyun karenge woh aisa ho nahi sakta IMF ka issue nahi hai IMF ka issue nahi hai dekhein dekhein ye dekhein ye na fluid situation hai
[32:36]yeh bada acha sawal hai aapka yeh bada fluid situation hai ke ji aaj agar let's say agle hafte mein kuch resolution nikal aata hai I am sure nikal aayega kyunki jis tarah se asan nazar a rahe hain baat ho rahi hai asal to aise hain just on a side note hain aisa waqe mein asar nahi bilkul hai na asar kyun nahi hai aap dekhein Iran ne do martaba apni jo hai woh tajawiz di hain dekhein woh toh woh toh abhi aapko front pe toh koi baat nahi karega na back end pe sare channels kaam kar rahe hain ye aapko Inshallah nazar aayega lekin main keh raha hoon ummeed hai ummeed bahut achi hai lekin main batata hoon worst case ki surat mein Prime Minister ne jo National Coordination Management Council banayi hai na woh char cheezein dekhiye mujhe sirf 30 seconds dein usme energy pehle finance minister ke under jo hai na energy prices ko dekha ja raha tha volumes ko dekha ja raha tha demand ko dekha ja raha tha kahan se kis tarah se source karna hai woh dekha ja raha tha aaj ye expand hoke energy se food commodities supply chain and finance sari cheezein trade bhi uske andar hai ye sab cheezein bit par dekhi ja rahi hain ke kiska agar scenario analysis ho raha hai ki agar let's say yahan se jang nahi rukti misal ke to par dobara koi hamla ho jata hai worst case leke chalna hai na humne toh hum toh ye nahi keh sakte best case lekar chalein hamesha government ka kaam hota hai worst case lekar chalna ke sabse worst case aa jaye to usme kya karenge woh agar aapne cover kar liya toh aap naturally phir sari cheezein cover kar sakte hain usme yeh hai ki aapke paas is waqt fuel behtar hai supply aapki insured hai aapki Saudi Arabia se financing arrange hui hai Saudi Arabia se aage jo hai extension ki baat ho rahi hai jo deferred us pe aapko oil milta hai na kimat baad mein de dein aaj aap oil fuel le lein hame woh at least milti ja rahi hain cheezein aur hum saath saath humara jo reserves hain woh behtar hain current account behtar hai so my question still stands ke hum log ye subsidy jo de rahe hain ye kab tak sustain kar sakte hain maine kaha ek ek mahina aage kar diya hai abhi filhal theek hai zarurat padegi toh mazid aage ki ja sakti hai lekin baat yeh hai ke aapko kahin na kahin pe limit define karni hogi na dekhein reforms bhi chal rahe hain saath saath abhi tak so far so good lekin main yeh kehna cha raha hoon ke hopefully prices ek 100 dollar pe bhi rehti hai to hum yeh manage kar sakte hain somehow lekin usse upar gayi agar to for example for example agar jang aaj khatam ho jati hai kal khatam ho jati hai agle hafte khatam ho jati hai even then bhi petroleum masnoat ki production toh us tarah se start nahi ho sakegi na it takes time to restart all that toh woh uska impact hum logon ne kitne arse ka socha hua hai dekhein mujhe lagta hai hamara jo ek plan hai woh yeh ke kam se kam dekhein ye global ek scenario analysis hai ke kam se kam teen se char mahine lag sakte hain zyada bhi lag sakte hain restore hone mein yani ke ye jo 20 percent supply ud gayi hai samjhein aap jab ud jati hai koi cheez toh usko fill in hone mein ya usko usko jo hai us khala ko pur karne mein thoda waqt lagta hai kyunki alternate pipelines dalti hain alternate routes hain aap dekhein aapko main thoda sa recall karwata hoon jab Russia aur Ukraine ki jang hui thi us waqt bhi 100 dollar 120 usse bhi zyada kimten gayi thi phir wapas aa gayi thi but pure saal ki average 100 dollar hui thi but that doesn't have a bigger global impact jitna iska hona chahiye bilkul sahi baat hai supply ka itna bada issue nahi hai lekin main phir wohi keh raha hoon jab prices badhti hain na toh naturally ek main aapko silver lining batata hoon iske baad naturally jo hai na supply dusre jo players hote hain woh lana shuru kar dete hain kyunki price ek khud incentive hota hai na badi prices hoti hai incentive hota hai ki supply aur lekar aaye
[36:26]main yeh bata raha hoon ki Opec ke andar UAE ke nikalna mujhe lagta hai ye silver lining hai kyunki cartel jo hota hai na duniya mein koi bhi cartels hote hain woh cartels bante hi isliye hain ki woh price ko bhi manage karein aur supply ko bhi manage karein toh agar cartel kamzor hota hai to usme kiska fayda hoga consumer ka fayda hoga kyunki jo bhi jo bhi player niklega woh uska compliant nahi hoga na woh kahega mujhe zyada kyunki unke yahan impact zyada aaya hai terrorism ka investment ka toh unko chahiye ke supply zyada lana supply zyada layenge to prices Inshallah niche aayengi aur obviously thoda sa ek aur woh toh straight of Homos ki side pe bhi hoke guzar sakta hai they can do that but but ek aur khabar kyunki aapne UAE ki baat kar di hai badi gardish kar rahi hai aur aap finance ministry se taluq rakhte hain to you will be able to tell us better hamare human resource ke saath kuch unfair situation ho rahi hai yeh khabren gardish kar rahi hain social media pe I want a denial or a confirmation nahi dekhiye denial to aapko MoFA de sakta hai proper kyunki hum toh finance ki taraf se dekhte hain lekin mera main aapko batata hoon ke dekhein abhi tak jo understanding hai woh aisi nahi hai jiss tarah se court kiya ja raha hai Pakistan aur UAE ke taluqat aise nahi ho gaye hain ki ji aap dekhein aap humare paas investments hain unki aap petroleum sector mein investment hai unki unki finance sector mein investment hai unki unki telecom mein investment hai itni badi ye cheezein is waqt mere khayal mein is tarah ki baat karte hain bagair hum research kiye hue ya bagair detail kiye hue toh ye thodi si thoda sa mujhe lagta hai irresponsible ho jati hai nahi pure social media pe ghum raha hai je main aapko batata hoon dekhein aap airlines ki baat ho rahi hai na woh aap Etihad wali baat kar rahi hongi ki Etihad airways se Pakistani nikal diye hain aap utha ke zara dekhein duniya ki kitni airlines jo hai woh is waqt khasaare mein ja rahi hain aur sabse zyada bechare ye Middle East wale hain kyunki inka scale bahut bada hai toh naturally trim karenge na HR ko dekhein ek cost hoti hai oil oil ki energy ki cost hoti hai airline ke liye chalane ke liye second cost aapki human resource hoti hai toh naturally jab oil jo hai niche nahi a raha aur unke yahan jo hai 50 50 hazaar flightein cancel ho rahi hain duniya bhar mein Western airlines hon ya aapki Middle Eastern hon aur uske saath agar woh retention karte hain to across the board hogi Pakistanis ke saath kyun karenge woh aisa ho nahi sakta IMF ka issue nahi hai IMF ka issue nahi hai dekhein dekhein ye dekhein ye na fluid situation hai
[38:36]yeh bada acha sawal hai aapka yeh bada fluid situation hai ke ji aaj agar let's say agle hafte mein kuch resolution nikal aata hai I am sure nikal aayega kyunki jis tarah se asan nazar a rahe hain baat ho rahi hai asal to aise hain just on a side note hain aisa waqe mein asar nahi bilkul hai na asar kyun nahi hai aap dekhein Iran ne do martaba apni jo hai woh tajawiz di hain dekhein woh toh woh toh abhi aapko front pe toh koi baat nahi karega na back end pe sare channels kaam kar rahe hain ye aapko Inshallah nazar aayega lekin main keh raha hoon ummeed hai ummeed bahut achi hai lekin main batata hoon worst case ki surat mein Prime Minister ne jo National Coordination Management Council banayi hai na woh char cheezein dekhiye mujhe sirf 30 seconds dein usme energy pehle finance minister ke under jo hai na energy prices ko dekha ja raha tha volumes ko dekha ja raha tha demand ko dekha ja raha tha kahan se kis tarah se source karna hai woh dekha ja raha tha aaj ye expand hoke energy se food commodities supply chain and finance sari cheezein trade bhi uske andar hai ye sab cheezein bit par dekhi ja rahi hain ke kiska agar scenario analysis ho raha hai ki agar let's say yahan se jang nahi rukti misal ke to par dobara koi hamla ho jata hai worst case leke chalna hai na humne toh hum toh ye nahi keh sakte best case lekar chalein hamesha government ka kaam hota hai worst case lekar chalna ke sabse worst case aa jaye to usme kya karenge woh agar aapne cover kar liya toh aap naturally phir sari cheezein cover kar sakte hain usme yeh hai ki aapke paas is waqt fuel behtar hai supply aapki insured hai aapki Saudi Arabia se financing arrange hui hai Saudi Arabia se aage jo hai extension ki baat ho rahi hai jo deferred us pe aapko oil milta hai na kimat baad mein de dein aaj aap oil fuel le lein hame woh at least milti ja rahi hain cheezein aur hum saath saath humara jo reserves hain woh behtar hain current account behtar hai so my question still stands ke hum log ye subsidy jo de rahe hain ye kab tak sustain kar sakte hain maine kaha ek ek mahina aage kar diya hai abhi filhal theek hai zarurat padegi toh mazid aage ki ja sakti hai lekin baat yeh hai ke aapko kahin na kahin pe limit define karni hogi na dekhein reforms bhi chal rahe hain saath saath abhi tak so far so good lekin main yeh kehna cha raha hoon ke hopefully prices ek 100 dollar pe bhi rehti hai to hum yeh manage kar sakte hain somehow lekin usse upar gayi agar to for example for example agar jang aaj khatam ho jati hai kal khatam ho jati hai agle hafte khatam ho jati hai even then bhi petroleum masnoat ki production toh us tarah se start nahi ho sakegi na it takes time to restart all that toh woh uska impact hum logon ne kitne arse ka socha hua hai dekhein mujhe lagta hai hamara jo ek plan hai woh yeh ke kam se kam dekhein ye global ek scenario analysis hai ke kam se kam teen se char mahine lag sakte hain zyada bhi lag sakte hain restore hone mein yani ke ye jo 20 percent supply ud gayi hai samjhein aap jab ud jati hai koi cheez toh usko fill in hone mein ya usko usko jo hai us khala ko pur karne mein thoda waqt lagta hai kyunki alternate pipelines dalti hain alternate routes hain aap dekhein aapko main thoda sa recall karwata hoon jab Russia aur Ukraine ki jang hui thi us waqt bhi 100 dollar 120 usse bhi zyada kimten gayi thi phir wapas aa gayi thi but pure saal ki average 100 dollar hui thi but that doesn't have a bigger global impact jitna iska hona chahiye bilkul sahi baat hai supply ka itna bada issue nahi hai lekin main phir wohi keh raha hoon jab prices badhti hain na toh naturally ek main aapko silver lining batata hoon iske baad naturally jo hai na supply dusre jo players hote hain woh lana shuru kar dete hain kyunki price ek khud incentive hota hai na badi prices hoti hai incentive hota hai ki supply aur lekar aaye
[42:26]main yeh bata raha hoon ki Opec ke andar UAE ke nikalna mujhe lagta hai ye silver lining hai kyunki cartel jo hota hai na duniya mein koi bhi cartels hote hain woh cartels bante hi isliye hain ki woh price ko bhi manage karein aur supply ko bhi manage karein toh agar cartel kamzor hota hai to usme kiska fayda hoga consumer ka fayda hoga kyunki jo bhi jo bhi player niklega woh uska compliant nahi hoga na woh kahega mujhe zyada kyunki unke yahan impact zyada aaya hai terrorism ka investment ka toh unko chahiye ke supply zyada lana supply zyada layenge to prices Inshallah niche aayengi aur obviously thoda sa ek aur woh toh straight of Homos ki side pe bhi hoke guzar sakta hai they can do that but but ek aur khabar kyunki aapne UAE ki baat kar di hai badi gardish kar rahi hai aur aap finance ministry se taluq rakhte hain to you will be able to tell us better hamare human resource ke saath kuch unfair situation ho rahi hai yeh khabren gardish kar rahi hain social media pe I want a denial or a confirmation nahi dekhiye denial to aapko MoFA de sakta hai proper kyunki hum toh finance ki taraf se dekhte hain lekin mera main aapko batata hoon ke dekhein abhi tak jo understanding hai woh aisi nahi hai jiss tarah se court kiya ja raha hai Pakistan aur UAE ke taluqat aise nahi ho gaye hain ki ji aap dekhein aap humare paas investments hain unki aap petroleum sector mein investment hai unki unki finance sector mein investment hai unki unki telecom mein investment hai itni badi ye cheezein is waqt mere khayal mein is tarah ki baat karte hain bagair hum research kiye hue ya bagair detail kiye hue toh ye thodi si thoda sa mujhe lagta hai irresponsible ho jati hai nahi pure social media pe ghum raha hai je main aapko batata hoon dekhein aap airlines ki baat ho rahi hai na woh aap Etihad wali baat kar rahi hongi ki Etihad airways se Pakistani nikal diye hain aap utha ke zara dekhein duniya ki kitni airlines jo hai woh is waqt khasaare mein ja rahi hain aur sabse zyada bechare ye Middle East wale hain kyunki inka scale bahut bada hai toh naturally trim karenge na HR ko dekhein ek cost hoti hai oil oil ki energy ki cost hoti hai airline ke liye chalane ke liye second cost aapki human resource hoti hai toh naturally jab oil jo hai niche nahi a raha aur unke yahan jo hai 50 50 hazaar flightein cancel ho rahi hain duniya bhar mein Western airlines hon ya aapki Middle Eastern hon aur uske saath agar woh retention karte hain to across the board hogi Pakistanis ke saath kyun karenge woh aisa ho nahi sakta IMF ka issue nahi hai IMF ka issue nahi hai dekhein dekhein ye dekhein ye na fluid situation hai
[44:36]yeh bada acha sawal hai aapka yeh bada fluid situation hai ke ji aaj agar let's say agle hafte mein kuch resolution nikal aata hai I am sure nikal aayega kyunki jis tarah se asan nazar a rahe hain baat ho rahi hai asal to aise hain just on a side note hain aisa waqe mein asar nahi bilkul hai na asar kyun nahi hai aap dekhein Iran ne do martaba apni jo hai woh tajawiz di hain dekhein woh toh woh toh abhi aapko front pe toh koi baat nahi karega na back end pe sare channels kaam kar rahe hain ye aapko Inshallah nazar aayega lekin main keh raha hoon ummeed hai ummeed bahut achi hai lekin main batata hoon worst case ki surat mein Prime Minister ne jo National Coordination Management Council banayi hai na woh char cheezein dekhiye mujhe sirf 30 seconds dein usme energy pehle finance minister ke under jo hai na energy prices ko dekha ja raha tha volumes ko dekha ja raha tha demand ko dekha ja raha tha kahan se kis tarah se source karna hai woh dekha ja raha tha aaj ye expand hoke energy se food commodities supply chain and finance sari cheezein trade bhi uske andar hai ye sab cheezein bit par dekhi ja rahi hain ke kiska agar scenario analysis ho raha hai ki agar let's say yahan se jang nahi rukti misal ke to par dobara koi hamla ho jata hai worst case leke chalna hai na humne toh hum toh ye nahi keh sakte best case lekar chalein hamesha government ka kaam hota hai worst case lekar chalna ke sabse worst case aa jaye to usme kya karenge woh agar aapne cover kar liya toh aap naturally phir sari cheezein cover kar sakte hain usme yeh hai ki aapke paas is waqt fuel behtar hai supply aapki insured hai aapki Saudi Arabia se financing arrange hui hai Saudi Arabia se aage jo hai extension ki baat ho rahi hai jo deferred us pe aapko oil milta hai na kimat baad mein de dein aaj aap oil fuel le lein
